Accessories:External Filters: Difference between revisions

From Beast Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
← Older edit
imported>Beastadmin
No edit summary
imported>Dl4mea
 
(10 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
==Basics==
Most of us do live in an area where they are not alone. Many transmitters are around us, not just those that we really want to receive. It is then the task of the receiver to make a selection of the radio spectrum that is actually of interest. This is done with filters at the input. Unfortunately, for the radar signals on 1090 MHz, such filters are either large or do have significant attenuation, usually 3dB (half of the signal is lost).
I decided not to put any filter at the input but instead use a proven high IP (Intercept Point) device directly at the input, which is significantly more robust against out-of-band signals as the low current amplifers used in others. I did not want to have this degradation at this point because these 3 dB loss fully adds to the noise figure and herewith to the sensitivity of the device. The Mode-S Beast much more should be a device mainly designed for sensitiviy. The story tells that only in a few cases strong out-of-band signals disturb reception, so this decision was correct.
Anyway, in just a few cases there are too strong signals degrading the Beast's performance. From my long-term RF experience I know that an external filter can be made so that the system performance does not degrade. These filters are large, based on a mechanical construction and not able to be integrated onto the PCB, as you see in below photos. But the parameters reached with these filters are really outstanding and worth the effort.
==The Filters==
==The Filters==


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|[[File:1090MHz-3Kreis-Filter-03.jpg|500px|1090 MHz 3 Kreis Filter ]]
|[[File:1090MHz-3Kreis-Filter-03.jpg|500px|thumb|1090 MHz 3 Pole Filter (with two N female connectors)]]
|picture to be added
|[[File:5pole filter-4-resized.jpg|500px|thumb|1090 MHz 5 Pole Filter]]
|-
|''The 3 pole filter (both ports N female)''
|''The 5 pole filter''
|-
|-
|<ins>Technical data:</ins><br>passband attenuation: 0.5 dB<br>-3 dB bandwidth: 13.5 MHz
|<ins>Technical data:</ins><br>passband attenuation: 0.5 dB<br>-3 dB bandwidth: 13.5 MHz
|<ins>Technical data:</ins><br>passband attenuation: 1.5 dB<br>-3 dB bandwidth: 8 MHz<br>(to be confirmed with next build)
|<ins>Technical data:</ins><br>passband attenuation: 1.2 dB<br>-3 dB bandwidth: 6.4 MHz
|}
|}


Line 31: Line 21:
Mode-S Beast with 5 pole filter: to be confirmed with next build
Mode-S Beast with 5 pole filter: to be confirmed with next build


TODO CALCULATOR
TODO ADD CALCULATOR SCRIPT


This calculation was created by my friend Luis Cupido, CT1DMK. Thanks, Luis!
This calculation was created by my friend Luis Cupido, CT1DMK. Thanks, Luis!
Line 41: Line 31:


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|[[File:3pole-narrow.gif|800px|The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30]]
|[[File:3pole-narrow.jpg|400px|The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30]]
|-
|-
|''The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30''
|''The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30''
Line 47: Line 37:


{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"
|[[File:3pole-vna-02.jpg|800px|Filter Measurements with a R&S ZVR VNA]]
|[[File:3pole-vna-02.jpg|400px|Filter Measurements with a R&S ZVR VNA]]
|[[File:3pole-s11b.jpg|400px|S11 and S22 with my own FSEA30 and a directional coupler]]
|-
|-
|''Filter Measurements with a R&S ZVR VNA''
|''Filter Measurements with a R&S ZVR VNA''
|''As an experiment, I also measured the S11 and S22 with my own FSEA30 and a directional coupler, and I got the same values as with the VNA with a very good reproduction''
|}
|}


As an experiment, I also measured the S11 and S22 with my own FSEA30 and a directional coupler, and I got the same values as with the VNA with a very good reproduction:
==Measurements of the 5 Pole Filter==
 
These are the measurements of the 5 pole filter. The few devices that .


[[File:3pole-s11b.gif|800px|S11 and S22 measured with Rohde & Schwarz FSEA30 and a directional coupler]]
{| class="wikitable"
|[[File:5pole-narrow.jpg|400px|The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30 and tracking generator]]
|[[File:5pole-wide.jpg|400px|The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30]]
|-
|''Narrow passband sweep''
|''Wideband sweep''
|}

Latest revision as of 16:34, 15 November 2013

The Filters

1090 MHz 3 Pole Filter (with two N female connectors)
1090 MHz 5 Pole Filter
Technical data:
passband attenuation: 0.5 dB
-3 dB bandwidth: 13.5 MHz 		Technical data:
passband attenuation: 1.2 dB
-3 dB bandwidth: 6.4 MHz

Why is there even a gain when inserting additional atttenuation?

When adding a external filter, we add attenuation and degrade the noise figure, but if at the same time the bandwidth becomes less, so less atmospheric noise passes through into the receiver. One can really see that the number of frames per second raises when the filter becomes inserted while the range increases a little bit.

Here is a calculator where you can enter noise figure and bandwidth of your system. You may edit the first two lines in below table in order to see the effect of an external filter. Video-Bandwidth and Sigma are best knowledge assumptions.

The original values as I claim are:

Mode-S Beast standalone: Noise Figure 2.0 dB, RF bandwidth 30 MHz Mode-S Beast with 3 pole filter: Noise Figure 2.5 dB, RF bandwidth 13.5 MHz (see measurements below) Mode-S Beast with 5 pole filter: to be confirmed with next build

TODO ADD CALCULATOR SCRIPT

This calculation was created by my friend Luis Cupido, CT1DMK. Thanks, Luis!


Measurements of the 3 Pole Filter

I measured the 3 pole filter shown above on my own Rohde&Schwarz FSEA30 (GIF grafics) as well as on a ZVRE Vector Network analyzer (photo screenshots). The passband attenuation of 0.5dB was measured with a R&S SMPC generator and a HP436 power meter in order to have a much better accuracy.

The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30
The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30
Filter Measurements with a R&S ZVR VNA S11 and S22 with my own FSEA30 and a directional coupler
Filter Measurements with a R&S ZVR VNA As an experiment, I also measured the S11 and S22 with my own FSEA30 and a directional coupler, and I got the same values as with the VNA with a very good reproduction

Measurements of the 5 Pole Filter

These are the measurements of the 5 pole filter. The few devices that .

The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30 and tracking generator The 3 pole passband measured with R&S FSEA30
Narrow passband sweep Wideband sweep
Retrieved from "https://wiki.jetvision.de/index.php?title=Accessories:External_Filters&oldid=2758"